Are True Story-Based Shows Authentic? Insights from the Writer of ‘Nobody Wants This’

In the world of television, where narratives often blur the line between truth and entertainment, writer Bruce Eric Kaplan offers a fascinating perspective on shows drawn from real-life experiences. Speaking exclusively to Us Weekly, Kaplan, known for his work on the acclaimed series Girls, emphasized that writers primarily aim to create compelling television, regardless of how closely it mirrors reality. “Every writer I’ve encountered is dedicated to crafting the best possible show,” Kaplan remarked, underlining that most audiences are aware that these narratives are not straightforward documentaries.

Kaplan, who has recently released a memoir titled They Went Another Way: A Hollywood Memoir, praised Lena Dunham, the creator and star of Girls, for her artistic commitment to authenticity. “Lena has a unique ability to convey her truth through her work,” he stated, noting that she approaches storytelling with sincere intentions. He recalled a particular Girls episode that, while humorous and deeply personal, ultimately didn’t air due to its specificity to someone from Dunham’s life. Despite the episode not being broadcast, Kaplan reflected fondly on the intriguing character it portrayed, indicating that the essence of the individual was strikingly accurate to Dunham’s description.

Even as viewers engage with these dramatizations, Kaplan urged caution against assuming that the dramatized events reflect a true account of real life. “The narratives can be inspired by reality, but they rarely present an exact replication,” he explained, highlighting the show’s creative liberties. In his current project, Kaplan noted that fellow writer Jenni Konner often reminds the team that while personal stories can be fascinating, the portrayal in a script may require careful modification to maintain believability.

With the show Nobody Wants This, which Kaplan is involved with, the exploration of love and relationships becomes intertwined with the creator Erin Foster’s own experiences. The series navigates the romantic entanglements of characters played by Kristen Bell and Adam Brody, all while drawing parallels to Foster’s real-life adventures.

In the broad landscape of television, as viewers continue to consume content that dances between fact and fiction, the insights of writers like Bruce Eric Kaplan remind us of the complexity and artistry behind these productions. His memoir provides a deeper look at the creative process within Hollywood, shedding light on how personal truths can serve as a foundation for captivating storytelling.