Driver Hopes Johnny and Matthew Gaudreau Survived Crash

The tragic story of Johnny and Matthew Gaudreau took a somber turn after they were struck and killed while riding their bicycles in Oldmans Township, New Jersey. The driver, Sean M. Higgins, expressed his hope that the brothers were still alive in the shocking aftermath of the incident. Body camera footage from the New Jersey State Police captures Higgins asking an officer, “Is everybody OK back there?” and “What happened?” Shortly after the crash on August 29, this exchange unfolded, leading to a deeper understanding of the grim circumstances.

The incident involved Johnny, 31, who made a name for himself as a standout player with the NHL’s Columbus Blue Jackets, and his brother Matthew, 29. The footage reveals that Higgins had been drinking prior to the collision and was driving from a nearby Taco Bell when he struck the brothers. He candidly admitted to having “five or six” beers since noon, but seemed unaware of the gravity of the situation, stating he hadn’t had a drink in “like two hours.”

During a field sobriety test conducted by officers, Higgins appeared visibly shaken and unsure, responding with anxiety about the situation. His blood-alcohol content was later measured at .087, exceeding New Jersey’s legal limit. Consequently, he faces serious charges, including two counts of vehicular homicide and other related offenses, potentially leading to a 20-year prison sentence if convicted.

911 audio released after the incident captured the urgent moments when bystanders reported the crash. A caller initially thought it was a hit-and-run but later corrected the statement, informing the dispatcher that the driver had pulled over. The caller described the dire scene, confirming both victims were on the ground and unable to see their conditions due to the darkness.

The Gaudreau family has received an outpouring of support since the tragic loss of Johnny and Matthew. Their mother, Jane Gaudreau, publicly expressed her gratitude for the heartfelt tributes and condolences shared by the community, particularly from those within the Columbus Blue Jackets organization.

Higgins’ case remains a pivotal focus, with court proceedings ongoing as the state prepares to file an indictment against him. His last court appearance was on November 12, where a 30-day extension was granted to the prosecution. The community continues to mourn the loss of two beloved brothers, as discussions surrounding accountability and justice unfold.